Week 5 Critiques

[Analeigh Tipton]

[Analeigh Tipton]

Congratulations, final 6! Unfortunately, we have to send one more of you home tonight. You all should be very proud of yourselves, I'm impressed with all 6 of you. Best of luck!

Alesha

Commercial:


Editorial:


Analeigh: I have to say, I'm quite impressed with you. You weren't doing very well early on, but you're turning your game around. Well done! Also, props for taking Nina's advice. I like the setting for both of the photos, but in both photos, your face doesn't speak to me. It's not as big of an issue in your commercial photo, but in the editorial photo you look downright bored. You do work those poses, though!

Nina: YAY I see backgrounds and props and other people. YAY, she listened to me !!! *so excited right now lol* What I like here is your different expressions. Commercial is happy, fun, flirty, cute, selling a product. You're doing that, and those legs look divine. Editorials are more edgy, more serious, more story telling. Again, you are doing that here. I like these both.

Colin: I really like both of these they're great in quality and apperance. Great job

Angelina

Commercial:


Editorial:


Analeigh: Your biggest problem here is the quality, the one in the commercial photo is really bad and it's a little weird in the editorial photo. I really do see commercial though, and one of my favorite things about you is that beautiful smile. The editorial one is alright, it just doesn't "wow" me. I'm not sure if I would hire you or not.

Nina: I'm not sure what happened but the quality of your commercial is completely awful. Your smile works but the quality is bothering me. Your editorial though, is completely one of my most favourite photos of you. It shows modeling value and it's unique. Very good there.

Colin: I have to agree the quality is the biggest problem I think if that photo had a better quality this would be a home run

Emily

Commercial:

Editorial:


Analeigh: The strongest photo here is definitely your commercial one. I love the pose and your face (although not so much the hair). The editorial one is a bit boring, but you have an intensity in your eyes. What I've noticed about you is that you try and be very safe- most of your photos have been strong, but a bit safe. I want to see some EXTREME from you, girl. Wow me! I would definitely commercially hire you, but I'm not sure about editorial.

Nina: Emily, your commercial is just wonderful!! The dress, the setting, the smile, the puppy!!! The editorial is good but not great. The pose and dress are nice but I really like my editorials to tell a story and I'm not feeling it here as much. You didn't do bad this round though.

Colin: The commercial is definitely your best photo I agree with the editorial about telling a story but I think I can see the beginning of a story in it

Eva

Commercial:


Editorial:


Analeigh: My problem is... I see more commercial in your "editorial" photo, and I see more editorial in your "commercial" photo, which really limits the judging here... I d o like both pictures, but the fact that they fit into the other category more than their own is a big problem. Not a fan this week.

Nina: Well. I was almost sold until I saw your comments. The first is editorial? I see no reason why? I understand why you chose the second one as commercial because there's a product but the whole photo just seems editorial to me. The lighting, the high fashion, the expression. I really love your second photo but I'm not liking your first one really at all, especially for editorial.

Colin: Your definitely a favorite of mine in this competition but I think that it's going to be a hard week for you this week because the photos are opposite of what they should be

JLo

Commercial:


Editorial:


Analeigh: I like this! I would have liked a connection to the camera in your commercial photo, but I love the smile. I think it be a little bit more high fashion, though? Still, I like it. Your editorial photo is great, though. You're alluring, you have a good connection to the camera, and you have a strong pose. Nice!

Nina: Nailed and oh yea Nailed!! You got it. Dead on. And managed to look gorgeous doing so. I'm really glad you were able to play instead of whomever never showed up. Although I worry about you because I've seen people play JLo horribly, you are doing a wonderful job. <3 Love fest over lol

Colin: This is my favorite photo this week I think there's nothing wrong with this photo everything that could be is great work

Lindsay

Commercial:


Editorial:


Analeigh: You totally nailed this shoot. Your commercial photo is great, you have a good pose, your eyes are strong... I also really like your editorial photo. The second photo, unfortunately, isn't AS strong, but I still love it. It's definitely editorial, your face is just a bit boring. I love the softness, though. Great job, I'd hire you.

Nina: Like JLo, you've nailed the theme at hand. My only complaint would be the quality on the second photo. But overall, you're doing well.

Colin: I like this my problem is I'd of like to see it in color

There you are, ladies!

Additionally, I asked all of the judges to say who they would hire and who they wouldn't. Here's the results:



Eliminations will be up shortly. Good luck!

[Emily VanCamp]

Congrats Lindsay on getting booked by all 3!!!

[Lindsay Lohan]

Awww love the judges!